Dr. Dick wrote:
"Human beings cannot even solve the problem of walking across the room by consciously deciding which muscles to contract and when. Anyone who tried to do so would be thought an idiot. Why do they think their mental image of the world was achieved by some conscious logical procedure?"
Dick, whenther you accept it or not my mental image of the world has in some measure been achieved by conscious logical procedures.
It was a breakthrough which I achieved in part
as a result of reading, in my youth, science fiction stories about robots. (How could fiction be conceived without a conscious logical procedure, by the way?)
Admittedly, your point would be valid if you only stated that our native condition is to run our minds the same way we run our bodies -- namely, to let the body's automatic functions
have their dominion. But you have in no way shown that, knowing our native tendency, we are unable to organize our own mental image of hte world acccording to conscious logical procedures.
However, when Dr. Dick says,"I have discovered a specific way to create a coherent illusion which will reproduce any random collection of data conceivable; a procedure which will provide an internally consistent set of entities and rules which will be totally and completely consistent with the data on which it is based". A Dewey decimal system of organizing absolutely any collection of data so to speak. And, just as an aside, it turns out that this illusion must obey most all of the accepted laws of physics" . . . then I am not necessarily denying that thesis. In fact, it seems to run counter to the former one I just quoted. I just don't think you know very much more than I do as a result
... if anything.
Have some pie -- Mike